brainwane: My smiling face, including a small gold bindi (Default)
brainwane ([personal profile] brainwane) wrote in [community profile] metafilter2019-01-19 03:08 pm

Seeking help with a front-page post

I'm pretty interested in the life of Dilip Singh Saund and am working on a front-page MetaFilter post about him. infini posted partially about him in 2012 but I have found some interesting materials to link to that I think weren't in that post. I would appreciate help framing and editing what I have.

A nonprofit hosts an instance of Etherpad, a collaborative document-editing platform, for anyone to use, so I've started an Etherpad to use in working on this post. There you can see the links and rough sequence I have so far.

I worry that I have a tendency to go on too long and cram too much stuff in to a post on the blue, so I would welcome "here's what I think are the most important/interesting parts here" comments so I can be more concise. Or "this is all great! Making a post that is everything including the kitchen sink is fine!" would also be welcome. Or, if you want to take over and write and post it to MeFi yourself, go ahead! Just speak up here and say you're going to do that, and credit me somewhere in the post.
calzephyr: Scott Pilgrim generator (Default)

[personal profile] calzephyr 2019-01-20 05:08 am (UTC)(link)
Do you have a title yet? Those are always a good hook :-)
sciatrix: A thumbnail from an Escher print, black and white, of a dragon with its tail in its mouth, wing outstretched behind. (Default)

[personal profile] sciatrix 2019-01-22 07:06 pm (UTC)(link)
I am definitely a kitchen sink kind of girl, me! Generally, if I approach an FPP with an eye to telling MeFi about a cool topic (vs. finding a link and wanting to share that), I'll basically use my links like sources. I'll dig up a bunch of links like you've done here, often with a sentence to the effect of "this source is good for XYZ," and then I'll compose a brief explanatory paragraph, using the links to "cite" each sentence or clause. Here are a few examples of that style. It's something I usually do if there's no good single post to introduce folks to the topic.

It usually works really well as long as you aren't hurt if people only read some of the links (or, sometimes, none of them).